I’ve just started a new, full time magazine gig, and so I wanted to
say so long to freelancing with links to some recent and less recent articles.
Instead, I wrote too long on just one of them, about Factory Girls author Leslie Chang.
The Chang article inspired a jealous response that, while it’s just a single, anonymous, online rant, probably isn’t that uncommon. Thirty years after China’s ‘opening up’, and with hundreds of thousands of expats living here, plenty of people still feel like they own ‘the China experience’, as if there is such a thing.
To put my own cards on the table, yes, I think Chang’s book is a sensitive and intelligent work of journalism and, uh huh, that she has a sense of humour, and, right, right, that everything in the comment below is nonsense, but I want to republish it as a case study in PRC player hating.
Has CNNGo become Hessler-Chang’s own private PR service? It seems like every other article on here is touting Peter Hessler and his wife. I understand they have written 4 books between them, but I do wonder why CNNGo feels they are deserving or so much over-exposure?
I read Factory Girls and thought the central theme was interesting, but Mrs. Chang acts like she herself “exposed” the entire industry, kind of like how Mr. Hessler goes on like he discovered China. Got ego?
Regarding Hessler-Chang’s upcoming move to Egypt, I understand that they are both journalists, but I find it extremely insulting, almost to the point of anger, that Mrs. Chang would say something as insensitive as “We almost wish that [protesters] had waited a year, just for the sake of our careers,” which says alot about her journalistic intentions. I see nothing admirable about getting paid a big advance by an American media company to go to places like China or Egypt and write about their contrived experiences there as the expense of the people suffering around them. Some “career!”
So basically, Mrs. Chang has already decided, without having ever been to Egypt, that “it’s going to be hard in many ways being a woman there, not having access to a lot of things and being harassed at various times…”, which is what we can probably expect her next book to be about: the hardships of a western women in a Muslim country. What a bunch of sensationalistic hooey!
And let me guess, Mr. Hessler’s publishers are already preparing to market his next book as the memoirs of “the first expat in Egypt.”
These two need a reality check, and their egos need to be taken down a few notches.
And… (sic). If you empathised with that comment, you won’t want to read the following gratuitous (fanboyish?) outtakes from the interview transcript that didn’t make the article.
On the Foxconn Suicides
“My feeling about the suicides is I don’t know, obviously, what specifically were the stories behind these young workers who tragically took their own lives, but in general, talking to workers and factory owners about suicides, they tended to come from just incredible emotional and personal pressures inside the factory. I mean, picture being 17 years old, being away from your family and your village for the first time, being in a dorm with nine other girls, nine other guys, having to deal with roommate conflicts, colleague conflicts, fighting with your boss, boyfriends, girlfriends, families giving you a lot of pressure at home. There’s a lot of personal pressures on these young people and that can be very, very hard to deal with.”
“When you think about it, if you hear about somebody that commits suicide you don’t automatically say oh god, his job situation must have been really terrible, you think he must have a lot of really huge personal burdens that he couldn’t deal with, or that combined with some sort of mental illness.”
On the pressures of development
“One of the reasons I loved writing about migrants was because I felt like it gets to the feeling of the emotional climate in China right now. People have this incredible opportunity – they’ve never had it before in their whole lives -but the result is not necessarily contentment and happiness. The result is often more pressure, more stress, this feeling that I have to do everything, I have to keep improving, I have to get my kid enrolled in piano lessons and English lessons and this and that otherwise I’ll fall behind, otherwise I’m going to lose out.
“So there’s this great sense of adventure and freedom but it’s often experienced by individuals as stress and pressure. I think that makes sense when you think about these people who’ve grown up with very stable, not at all inspiring or opportunity filled lives, but very stable and suddenly to have this chaotic freedom that so many people have in China now, I think it’s very easy to lose your bearings. I think people do surprisingly, remarkably well.
“When you talk to any Chinese person in their 30s or 40s, the life they grew up with is so different to the life they have now. And the life their children have now is so different from the life they grew up with.”
On the changing nature of migration in China
“I think it’s somewhat changing in that there are more and more interior cities that are developed enough to support their own industries and offer employment to young people from nearby villages, so now you’re seeing people who don’t have to go all the way to Dongguan or Shenzhen or Shanghai for work but they can go to Changsha or Chongqing or Hefei or whatever and that’s only a few hours from their home and they can go home on the weekend.
“So you’re seeing that, and I think that’s obviously very helpful because it means that economic growth is spreading out and it’s not just concentrated on the coasts. It’s possibly healthier and easier for young people not to have to cut ties with their family to work – they can sort of have it both ways. So in that sense I think migration is probably less dramatic than it is for people going hundreds of miles from home. But in terms of the general trend I think that migration still has miles to go.”
On the new middle class
“I do think a lot of the migrant workers will and are moving into the middle class, it’s just they don’t do it through college and the education system. They’re doing it through moving into the city, working and saving up some money and then getting married and buying an apartment, having a child and then they move into the, you know, not middle middle class, but a lower middle class in a big city. I do see that huge transformation and huge social mobility happening through migration and employment rather than education.
“One of the most interesting things about Dongguan was this informal, commercial education system that had grown up to make up for education they hadn’t had in school. I think the Chinese education system is extremely not pragmatic, and then this Dongguan commercial system is extremely pragmatic, just hyper pragmatic – everything is just focused on getting a job, not even really on learning anything, skills or ethics, but just talking your way into a job. So yeah, there’s a lot of education in Dongguan that’s completely opposite to the elite classical education system.”
On Hessler’s influence
“Definitely, he influenced me more if you want to quantify it just because he was more developed as a writer at the time that I started working on Factory Girls. He’s a huge influence and he was encouraging me for years to leave the Journal and write a book – this is the only way to go, keep your eyes open.
“When I started thinking about the migrants, initially I was working on another project and I said maybe I could talk about my colleagues and we could each do a piece about a migrant, have a series – five different people, five different stories . And he said you know writing is not a group activity. You should do this all yourself, you know.
“The minute I started working on it I realized that there was probably a book in it. So then I started working on it and when I finally finished the research and started writing the book I wrote the first three chapters and gave them to him to look at, not to edit, but tell me if you think it’s on the right track and he said, yeah, you’re fine, just keep going. At key points all the way through he was always encouraging and always interested.”
On their decision to move to the Middle East
“We didn’t want it to be a place that was like China but less so, so that ‘X’ed out a lot of places. And then we wanted it to be a place that was of interest to global readers and Western, American editors. So that narrows down the places you might wanna live in but don’t have a lot of selling power when it comes to magazines and books.
“We decided that the Middle East is a fascinating and probably misunderstood place and we had a feeling that it’s similar to how China was when we first arrived, in that the coverage seems to be largely political. In fact, there are certainly a lot of economic and social stories going on there that are probably fascinating but that people are not writing.
“Probably it’s just because they have their hands full and because they’re not spending a lot of time places and really getting to see the story that might be more subtle and take more time because the political stories are always big and pressing. There are probably a lot of fascinating personal stories, a lot of humour, a lot of quirks, a lot of interestingness and hopefully we can study Arabic and get to know these stories.”